Destination comparison
New England vs Saint Lucia
Two distinct sailing grounds — here's how they compare on conditions, cost, season, and who they suit.
Quick Comparison
| Dimension | New England | Saint Lucia |
|---|---|---|
| Region | US East Coast & Florida | Caribbean |
| Peak season | Jul, Aug, Sep | Dec, Jan, Feb, Mar, Apr |
| Shoulder | Jun, Oct | Nov, May |
| Sailing difficulty | easy to moderate | moderate to difficult |
| Recommended level | intermediate | intermediate |
| Avg wind (winter / summer) | 20 / 11 kn | 18 / 14 kn |
| Hurricane risk | Aug, Sep, Oct | Aug, Sep, Oct |
| Currency | USD | XCD (pegged to USD) |
| Mid-tier price (7 days) | $13,500 | $10,000 |
| Luxury tier price | $60,000 | $38,000 |
| Detail page | View → | View → |
At a Glance
A short but beloved season: fleets launch after Memorial Day and haul out by mid-October. July-September delivers 75-85°F days, classic sea breezes and picture-perfect harbours from Narragansett Bay to Penobscot Bay. Fog and strong tides on the Maine coast reward careful planning.
- • 2 base marinas
- • 3 must-visit anchorages
- • 11 boats in our fleet database for this region
Northern end of Windward chain; longer passages. Pitons protected area. Strong Atlantic swells December-April.
- • 2 base marinas
- • 4 must-visit anchorages
- • 31 boats in our fleet database for this region
Sailing Conditions
New England averages 20 knots in winter and 11 knots in summer. Hurricane risk runs Aug, Sep, Oct — outside these months the sailing is generally dependable.
Saint Lucia averages 18 knots in winter and 14 knots in summer. Hurricane risk: Aug, Sep, Oct.
In terms of sailing difficulty, New England is generally rated easy to moderate and Saint Lucia is moderate to difficult. The difference matters: Saint Lucia asks more of the skipper — confidence at the helm and some experience with coastal navigation helps.
Cost Comparison
For a 7-day charter of a typical 45-ft catamaran (4 cabins, sleeps 8):
- Low season: $5,200
- Mid season: $13,500
- High season: $30,000
- Luxury / crewed peak: $60,000+
- Low season: $3,800
- Mid season: $10,000
- High season: $19,000
- Luxury / crewed peak: $38,000+
Bareboat base rates. Crewed typically adds ~$1,500/day (captain + hostess). Prices exclude fuel, provisioning, mooring fees, gratuity.
Anchorages & Must-Do
- Martha's Vineyard & Nantucket — Iconic New England harbours - Edgartown and Nantucket Town on the mooring field
- Newport & Narragansett Bay — Gilded-Age mansions, America's Cup history and the best cruising chandlery in the NE
- Penobscot Bay, Maine — Granite islands, lobster harbours and Camden Hills - the cruising classic
- Pitons (UNESCO) — Twin volcanic peaks; iconic St Lucia
- Soufrière — Drive-in or anchor; sulfur springs
- Marigot Bay — Dramatic hurricane hole
- Anse Cochon — Sheltered cove
Which Should You Choose?
Both work for first-timers. The default choice for the industry is BVI; choose that unless you have specific reasons to prefer New England or Saint Lucia.
Choose Saint Lucia. Warmer water year-round (often 75–85°F), palm-fringed anchorages.
New England has 0 cultural anchorages vs Saint Lucia's 1. Pick by what kind of stop you want between swims.
Captain's Take
"New England's season is short and worth planning around. July-September is the sweet spot, but each month has its own character: July is warmest, August brings the whale-watching off Stellwagen Bank, September has the best breeze and the emptiest harbours after Labor Day. Fog is the real hazard on the Maine coast - if you see it building, tuck into a harbour early; it rarely clears before noon."
Timing and Budget: New England vs Saint Lucia
Frequently Asked Questions
Is New England or Saint Lucia better for a first-time charter? ▾
Which is cheaper to charter — New England or Saint Lucia? ▾
When is the best time to visit New England vs Saint Lucia? ▾
How do sailing conditions compare — New England vs Saint Lucia? ▾
Which has better flight access — New England or Saint Lucia? ▾
Which is more beginner-friendly, New England or Saint Lucia? ▾
Choose Between New England & Saint Lucia
Tell us your dates and group. We'll recommend the right one — honestly.